difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
#1
difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
Hi fellow H3 owners. I was using the search feature to find out about a question: What would be the advantages by changing the stock filter for a K&N one.
2007 Birch white, Lux package, sunroof,towing package.
purchace the H3 last saturday.
2007 Birch white, Lux package, sunroof,towing package.
purchace the H3 last saturday.
#2
RE: difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
If you are talking about the flat panel type filters, the difference is the medium material. K&N uses a gauze type fabric impregnatated with oil to capture the dirt. It has less restriction thus a few more horsepower. The trade off is the OEM Paper filter traps more dirt and takes better care of your engine. Also give thought to the larger conical filters like the K&N.
#3
RE: difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
My H3 did not come with a panel filter. Mine came with a paper cone filter. I switched to the K&N one about 3 months after I purchased it, but the problem is you have to clean the oil off the resistors of the Mass Air-Flow sensor once in a while, or they will produce inaccurate readings. The oil from the K&N filter starts to build up on the sensor. If you don't, over time the MAF will become so dirty your H3 will start to run bad.
#4
RE: difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
This topic is old..but I will still add my 2 cents..
On my H3 the stock filter is round and cylindrical and also oil coated...But I have the K&N CAI now and I feel since K&N has been aroud for a very long time in this type of business, that they know what they are doing..So I think the protection is goodif not better than the paper filters and will allow more air flow compared to the paper ones when they are dirty...On the K&N, Cleaning and re-oiling is where people get into trouble by over oiling the filter...So I gree though if you are off roading in real dust conditions a paper filter maybe better..but not to worry aboput a K&N in everyday driving...
Bottom line..you only need to buy one K&N for the life of the car, whereas, you will spend 10 times that amount of one K&N to keep replacing your stock filter every year.
On my H3 the stock filter is round and cylindrical and also oil coated...But I have the K&N CAI now and I feel since K&N has been aroud for a very long time in this type of business, that they know what they are doing..So I think the protection is goodif not better than the paper filters and will allow more air flow compared to the paper ones when they are dirty...On the K&N, Cleaning and re-oiling is where people get into trouble by over oiling the filter...So I gree though if you are off roading in real dust conditions a paper filter maybe better..but not to worry aboput a K&N in everyday driving...
Bottom line..you only need to buy one K&N for the life of the car, whereas, you will spend 10 times that amount of one K&N to keep replacing your stock filter every year.
#5
RE: difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
Thanks for the reply Dvader. The one I talking about is the cilinder looking one on the K&N site. More or less how many HP more. I donot want to use the CAI system because it makes to much noice.
#6
RE: difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
ORIGINAL: Dennis
This topic is old..but I will still add my 2 cents..
On my H3 the stock filter is round and cylindrical and also oil coated...But I have the K&N CAI now and I feel since K&N has been aroud for a very long time in this type of business, that they know what they are doing..So I think the protection is goodif not better than the paper filters and will allow more air flow compared to the paper ones when they are dirty...On the K&N, Cleaning and re-oiling is where people get into trouble by over oiling the filter...So I gree though if you are off roading in real dust conditions a paper filter maybe better..but not to worry aboput a K&N in everyday driving...
Bottom line..you only need to buy one K&N for the life of the car, whereas, you will spend 10 times that amount of one K&N to keep replacing your stock filter every year.
This topic is old..but I will still add my 2 cents..
On my H3 the stock filter is round and cylindrical and also oil coated...But I have the K&N CAI now and I feel since K&N has been aroud for a very long time in this type of business, that they know what they are doing..So I think the protection is goodif not better than the paper filters and will allow more air flow compared to the paper ones when they are dirty...On the K&N, Cleaning and re-oiling is where people get into trouble by over oiling the filter...So I gree though if you are off roading in real dust conditions a paper filter maybe better..but not to worry aboput a K&N in everyday driving...
Bottom line..you only need to buy one K&N for the life of the car, whereas, you will spend 10 times that amount of one K&N to keep replacing your stock filter every year.
#7
RE: difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
And just so you know, I DO remember us having this conversation before, BEFORE you post a link to another post from when we had this conversation, and I remember you saying your MAF was clean, but I would take a Q-tip to it, DRY, and see if anything comes off of it. I bet it's black after you do so.
#9
RE: difference betwen stock filter & K&N filter
I wouldn't use contact cleaner if I were you. Besides it being a liquid based oil and not a solid, the pressure from the spray may break the resistor lead. They are very sensitive to bending. I take it back; I would use 70% isopropyl alcohol on a cotton swap and very gentaly go over the resistor itself. As I said, mine looked normal, until I found out they weren't supposed to be black It's hard to tell the oil is on there because there are/were no caked-on dirt particles or dust sticking to it, so it looked clean. I'm also going to check it today or this weekend. I may just replace it with a stock filter. My H3 has alot of miles on it already and I'm starting to get a little weary about putting thingson there that may minutely cause engine problems. I'm also looking into the extended warranty (well, Mike is looking into it for me). I'm willing to shell out 2K if it means I'm under warranty for another 5 years with no worries.